Top 10 Must-Try Dishes in Monmouth County: A Local's Perspective

Aug 18, 2025By Gourmet Hospitality Group
Gourmet Hospitality Group

Exploring Monmouth County's Culinary Scene

Monmouth County, nestled along the Jersey Shore, offers a delightful array of culinary experiences that will tantalize your taste buds. Whether you're a local or just visiting, there are some dishes that simply can't be missed. Here's a local's perspective on the top 10 must-try dishes in Monmouth County.

1. Red Bank's Famous Lobster Roll

If you're in Red Bank, the lobster roll is a must. This classic New England favorite is served with a Jersey twist, featuring chunks of succulent lobster meat tossed in a light mayo dressing and tucked into a perfectly toasted bun. It's a summer staple you won't want to miss.

lobster roll

2. Asbury Park's Artisan Pizza

Asbury Park is not just famous for its boardwalk and music scene; it's also home to some incredible artisan pizza. With thin, crispy crusts and innovative toppings like truffle oil and arugula, these pizzas are a gourmet delight.

3. Long Branch's Pier Fries

No visit to Long Branch is complete without indulging in pier fries. These golden, crispy fries are best enjoyed with a sprinkle of vinegar or a side of cheese sauce while you take in the ocean views.

french fries beach

4. Atlantic Highlands' Seafood Paella

For a taste of Spain by the sea, head to Atlantic Highlands where you'll find a seafood paella that bursts with flavor. This dish is a magnificent blend of saffron-infused rice, fresh shellfish, and tender chicken.

5. Freehold's Classic Diner Breakfast

Nothing beats the comforting allure of a classic diner breakfast in Freehold. From fluffy pancakes to perfectly cooked omelets, these morning delights will start your day off right.

diner breakfast

6. Keyport's Fresh Oysters

Keyport is renowned for its fresh seafood, and oysters are the star of the show. Enjoy them raw on the half shell with a squeeze of lemon, or try them broiled for a warm, savory treat.

7. Belmar's Grilled Cheese

The humble grilled cheese gets an upgrade in Belmar. These gourmet sandwiches feature artisanal breads and a variety of melted cheeses, often paired with unique ingredients like apple slices or bacon jam.

grilled cheese sandwich

8. Sea Bright's Fish Tacos

Head to Sea Bright for some of the best fish tacos around. Freshly caught fish is battered and fried to perfection, then served in soft tortillas with tangy slaw and creamy avocado.

9. Rumson's Artisan Chocolates

Satisfy your sweet tooth with Rumson's artisan chocolates. Handcrafted with high-quality cocoa and imaginative fillings, these chocolates are perfect for gifting—or keeping all to yourself.

chocolates

10. Middletown's Farm-to-Table Salad

For those seeking healthier options, Middletown offers farm-to-table salads that shine with local produce. These vibrant dishes showcase fresh greens, seasonal vegetables, and house-made dressings.

Whether you're a longtime resident or a curious traveler, Monmouth County's diverse culinary landscape promises an unforgettable gastronomic journey. From seaside classics to gourmet innovations, these dishes are sure to leave you craving more.

G-YYC5Q3RY6E